Pizza in Oyster Bay, NY
2 pizzerias listed · Updated Oct 27, 2026
Find pizzerias in Oyster Bay for dine-in, takeout, delivery and party trays.
Avahere lists 2 pizzerias in Oyster Bay, NY (11771). Of these, 1 show a public phone number, 2 link to a website and 1 list a street address. Oyster Bay is a hamlet in the Town of Oyster Bay; this page also covers Centre Island, Cove Neck, Oyster Bay Cove. Nearby, Bayville has 1 and Woodbury has 1. None of these businesses has claimed its page yet, so the details come from public business records.
Results
More pizza near Oyster Bay
Listed in nearby towns. Many local businesses travel to customers across the area.
Papa John's Pizza
UnclaimedNo reviews yetPizzeriaGlen Head · 4.8 mi away
36 Glen Head Rd Unit B, Glen Head
Sergio's Pizzeria Restaurant
UnclaimedNo reviews yetPizzeriaGlen Head · 4.8 mi away
Serves Glen Head and nearby
Pizza in Oyster Bay: common questions
How many pizzerias are in Oyster Bay, NY?
How do I contact a pizzeria listed here?
I run a pizzeria business. How do I update my listing?
Is Avahere free?
Listings come from public business records and from business owners. Avahere does not show owner names or private contact details. Spot a mistake or want a listing removed? Remove a listing or contact us.